Monday, August 18, 2008
More on Plantinga, Divine Simplicity
It would seem that Catholics, at least, cannot follow Plantinga in his claim that God is other than his nature (philosophical arguments aside, for the moment), due to the decrees of the council of Rheims against Peter of Poitiers. Of course, it was not an ecumenical council, but its decrees are included in Denzinger. In any case here it is, #745
Quod divina essentia, substantia et natura, quae dicitur divinitas, bonitas, sapientia, magnitudo Dei, et quaeque similia, non sit Deus, sed forma, qua est Deus.
that the divine essence, substance and nature which is called the divinity, goodness, wisdom, magnitude of God, and suchlike, is not God, but a form by which God is.